Shelter Island property records
3,306 properties on 200 streets in Shelter Island, Suffolk County, Long Island. Newest recorded sale 09/25/2026.
Recent sales
- 11 Shore Rd09/25/2026
- 37 Lake Dr09/25/2026
- 6 Winthrop Rd09/25/2026
- 164 Ferry Rd09/25/2026
- 172 Ferry Rd09/25/2026
- 7 Lake Dr09/18/2026 · $2,412,500
- 16 Shelterlands Path09/16/2026 · $1,140,000
- 28 Menantic Rd09/15/2026 · $5,850,000
- 14a Heron Ln09/10/2026
- 15 Congdon Rd09/01/2026 · $1,350,000
- 14a Midway Rd08/27/2026
- 10 Hillside Dr08/24/2026
- 12 Hillside Dr08/24/2026
- 21 Westmoreland Dr08/12/2026
- 26 Ole Buck Run08/06/2026 · $995,000
- 6 Westmoreland Dr08/04/2026
- 26 Ram Island Rd08/04/2026
- 8 Little Ram Island Dr07/31/2026 · $9,000,000
- 52 Midway Rd07/31/2026 · $3,025,000
- 13 Brander Pkwy07/31/2026
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
- Sandpiper Rd11
- School St5
- Seagate Rd5
- Seagull Rd10
- Serpentine Dr13
- Sheep Pasture Ln6
- Shelterlands Path17
- Shore Rd20
- Shorewood Ct4
- Shorewood Rd14
- Silver Beach Rd8
- Simpson Ave9
- Sleepy Hollow Rd12
- Smith St52
- South St2
- Southwick Ln10
- Spring Garden Ave15
- St. James St1
- St. Johns St5
- St. Mary'S Rd29
- Stearns Point Rd48
- Strawberry Ln16
- Strobel Rd3
- Summerfield Pl7
- Sunnyside Ave10
- Sunset Ln3
- Sunshine Rd19
- Sylvan Pl5
- Sylvan Rd18
- Sylvester Rd4